
New York has begun a process to revolutionize how people go to the toilet, as 17 brand-new high-tech restrooms are set to pop up across the city — yet they come with one major catch.
When most people think of a futuristic toilet they imagine heated seats, self-cleaning technology, and perhaps even a voice that speaks to you while you pee — yet the reality is often far more disappointing.
Implemented as part of a $4 million pilot program, as per Gothamist, free toilets operated by Throne Labs in New York City will now kick you out if you spend too long inside, with the door opening automatically after 10 minutes of use.
While it's bound to help New Yorkers when they're out and about with nowhere to go, it does introduce a complication that might make more difficult toilet trips even more stressful than they already are, leading some to brand the scheme 'dystopian'.
What happens when you reach the time limit?
According to Throne Labs, all individuals who enter one of the new toilets will be subject to the 10-minute time limit, and you'll be met with a warning alarm alerting you to the imminent opening of the door.
Advert
If you've still not left the toilet by the time the 10 minutes are up, however, another warning will be activated with a voice declaring: "Attention: Your use time has expired. The door is opening now."

This will then slide open the entrance door, theoretically exposing you to the public when you're in the middle of a toilet trip — so don't spend too long doomscrolling on your phone, especially as that brings about other concerning issues.
Additionally, there is also a protocol for when someone still refuses to leave the toilet even after the door has opened, with Throne Labs sending an individual and even the potential for the police to be called if the situation escalates.
Access issues are also raised amid concerns
Beyond the obcenity of exposing toilet-goers, another major issue that has been raised is access, as to use the toilets you either need to text a number via your smartphone, or use a special tap access card that is distributed to community partners.
The latter is designed to provide a solution to people who might not have access to a smartphone, but many have still expressed worries that homeless individuals could be blocked from using the toilets, especially amid growing public urination callouts.
"We are concerned that it raises several access issues for homeless New Yorkers," explained the Free to Pee Coalition, which is led by VOCAL-NY and the Coalition for the Homeless.
"Many may not have a smartphone or be able to easily obtain a physical tap card to open these restrooms [...] Modular bathrooms alone will not change the current imbalance in bathroom access."
Why these toilets are being built
While a myriad of issues have emerged amid the emergence of these high-tech toilets, the public bathrooms do serve a unique purpose that should provide a net benefit to the city as a whole.
The toilets – which have already been installed in Brooklyn and Queens before continuing to spread – are noted as being 'clean' and 'modern', with the hands-free nature viewed as a particular bonus when it comes to cleanliness.

Additionally, the toilets feature free pad dispensers to help people out in a sanitary emergency, and are also far cheaper and easier to install as they aren't connected to the city's sewer and water systems, meaning that a successful roll-out could see significant expansion.
Supreena Bacon, who was one of the first to use the new toilets in Brooklyn, said: "I hope people just enjoy and take care of it so we can, you know, as a neighbor, we can prove that we can have nice stuff around."
New York City Mayor Zohran Mamdani also emphasized the benefits of these new public restrooms, declaring that "too many New Yorkers know what it's like to have nowhere to go while they're on the go.
"This pilot is about making sure New Yorkers can count on a clean, safe, accessible bathroom when they need one," he continued.