DNA project helps solve 27-year mystery as man's leg washes up on a beach

Home> News

DNA project helps solve 27-year mystery as man's leg washes up on a beach

A banker went missing back in 1999

google discoverFollow us on Google Discover

A mystery stretching back 27 years has just been solved by a DNA project, as scientists have identified the individual behind a leg bone that washed up on a California beach two years ago.

There are countless John and Jane Does that police investigators have to deal with every single year, as not everyone who is found is able to be identified — even with the sophisticated modern technology operated by law enforcement.

Many of these so-called 'cold cases' can lie dormant forever, with no new evidence or information coming forward that brings investigators to a conclusion, yet one fascinating discovery led to answers in a missing persons case dating all the way back to 1999.

One family looking for sea shells on Salmon Creek Beach in Sonoma County, California nearly four years ago found something rather unexpected buried within the sand, as they pulled out a long human bone that appeared to contain surgical hardware.

A long human bone with surgical hardware was discovered by a family on Salmon Creek Beach in 2022 (George Rose/Getty Images)
A long human bone with surgical hardware was discovered by a family on Salmon Creek Beach in 2022 (George Rose/Getty Images)

Stunned by their discovery they immediately reported it to the police, who then conducted a pathological examination to reveal that the bone was a tibia containing potentially illuminating DNA.

The local Sheriff's Office then enlisted the help of the DNA Doe Project, a group of expert investigative genealogists working pro-bono on cases like this, who have detailed their miraculous discovery in a jaw-dropping news release.

These experts managed to craft a DNA profile from the tibia, which was then uploaded to the GEDmatch database earlier this year. Following this, a family settled within the San Diego area was identified, and an unexpected mystery was unearthed within their history.

They found that the family contained Walter Karl Kinney, a banker born in 1940 who went missing in Santa Rosa – just a short distance from Salmon Creek – back in 1999.

Walter Karl Kinney went missing in 1999, and the recent bone discovery has been confirmed to be his own (DNA Doe Project)
Walter Karl Kinney went missing in 1999, and the recent bone discovery has been confirmed to be his own (DNA Doe Project)

What's perhaps even more remarkable is that Kinney had already been a one-time John Doe, as partial human remains washed ashore in the year he went missing were later discovered to be from the banker in 2003, and the same has happened again this year.

Traci Onders, a team leader at the DNA Doe Project, explained that "the case was unusual — it's not often we see someone end up as a John Doe twice, but thanks to the investigative genetic genealogy, we were able to resolve this mystery and provide some answers to everyone involved in this case."

It goes to show quite how impressive and through the science behind this type of investigative work can be, but it also takes research outside of the lab and a bit of luck as always to find the answers that you're looking for.

Featured Image Credit: DNA Doe Project